You are currently viewing a snapshot of taken on April 21, 2008. Most of this content is highly out of date (some pages haven't been updated since the project began in 1998) and exists for historical purposes only. If there are any pages on this archive site that you think should be added back to, please file a bug.

Release Notes for Preview Version 8.4 - Feb, 2008

Table of Contents

  1. Hardware/Software Requirements
  2. HTTP Server Requirements
  3. W3C XForms - Document Structure
  4. W3C XForms - Processing Model
  5. W3C XForms - Datatypes
  6. W3C XForms - Model Item Properties
  7. W3C XForms - XPath Expressions in XForms
  8. W3C XForms - Form Controls
  9. W3C XForms - XForms User Interface
  10. W3C XForms - XForms Actions
  11. W3C XForms - Submit
  12. Security and Cross Domain Submission
  13. Styling XForms
  14. Comments and Filing Bugs
  15. Where to Find More Information

1. Hardware/Software Requirements

Windows (Client)

Operating Systems: 98 Second Edition, Millenium Edition, NT 4.0, 2000, XP
Processor: Pentium 233MHz (or faster)
Memory: 64MB
Disk Space: 52MB

Linux (Client)

Operating Systems: RedHat 7.0 (or later), Debian 3.0 (or later), SuSE 7.2 (or later)

Or a version of Linux with kernel 2.2.14 (or later) and the following library versions (or compatible):

  • glibc 2.2
  • GTK 1.2.x (1.2.5 preferred)
  • XFree86 3.3.x
  • libstdc++ 2.9.0
Processor: Pentium 233MHz (or faster)
Memory: 64MB
Disk Space:  52MB

Mac (Client)

Operating Systems: Mac OS X 10.1.x
Mac OS X 10.2.x (or later)
Processor: G3 266MHz
Memory:  64MB
Disk Space:  72MB

2. HTTP Server Requirements

The HTTP server must be able to serve XHTML (i.e., application/xhtml+xml) content.

3. Document Structure

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
3.1 Namespaces supported
3.2.1 Common Attributes supported
3.2.2 Linking Attributes supported
3.2.3 Single-Node Binding Attributes supported
3.2.4 Node-Set Binding Attributes supported
3.2.5 Model Item Property Attributes partial In some cases a loop error can occur on valid bindings 302168;
3.3.1 model supported
3.3.2 instance partial instance element with two child element does not trigger exception 337302;
3.3.3 submission partial No support for @indent and complex schema validation 278761; 278762;
3.3.4 bind partial Using the index() function in binds does not work. 292333;
3.4 Extension Module unsupported 300760;
3.5 MustUnderstand Module unsupported 300757;

4. Processing Model (Events)

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
4 Processing Model (Events) partial The xforms-recalculate, xforms-revalidate, and xforms-refresh events are not as separated as they should be. Event context information is also currently unsupported. 278448; 338146;
4.2 Initialization Events supported
4.2.1 xforms-model-construct supported
4.2.2 xforms-model-construct-done supported
4.2.3 xforms-ready supported
4.2.4 xforms-model-destruct supported
4.3.1 xforms-rebuild supported
4.3.2 xforms-recalculate supported
4.3.3 xforms-revalidate supported
4.3.4 xforms-refresh supported
4.3.5 xforms-reset supported
4.3.6 xforms-next xforms-previous supported
4.3.7 xforms-focus supported
4.3.8 xforms-help xforms-hint supported
4.3.9 xforms-submit partial see section 11.2 for more details
4.3.10 xforms-submit-serialize supported
4.4 Notification Events supported
4.4.1 xforms-insert supported
4.4.2 xforms-delete supported
4.4.3 xforms-value-changed supported
4.4.4 xforms-valid supported
4.4.5 xforms-invalid supported
4.4.6 xforms-readonly supported
4.4.7 xforms-readwrite supported
4.4.8 xforms-required supported
4.4.9 xforms-optional supported
4.4.10 xforms-enabled supported
4.4.11 xforms-disabled supported
4.4.12 DOMActivate supported
4.4.13 DOMFocusIn supported
4.4.14 DOMFocusOut supported
4.4.15 xforms-select xforms-deselect supported
4.4.16 xforms-in-range supported
4.4.17 xforms-out-of-range supported
4.4.18 xforms-scroll-first xforms-scroll-last supported
4.4.19 xforms-submit-done supported
4.5 Error Indications partial We don't support the xforms-version-exception event, yet
4.5.1 xforms-binding-exception supported
4.5.2 xforms-compute-exception supported
4.5.3 xforms-link-error partial Not yet generated by load. 333782;
4.5.4 xforms-link-exception supported
4.5.5 xforms-output-exception unsupported
4.5.6 xforms-submit-error supported
4.5.7 xforms-version-exception unsupported
4.6 Event Sequencing supported
4.6.1 For input, secret, textarea, range, or upload Controls supported
4.6.2 For output Controls supported
4.6.3 For select or select1 Controls partial
4.6.4 For trigger Controls supported
4.6.5 For submit Controls supported
4.6.6 Sequence: Selection Without Value Change supported
4.6.7 Sequence: Value Change With Focus Change supported
4.6.8 Sequence: Activating a Trigger supported
4.6.9 Sequence: Submission supported
4.7 Resolving ID References in XForms unsupported
4.7.1 References to Elements within a repeat Element unsupported
4.7.2 References to Elements within a bind Element unsupported
4.8 DOM Interface for Access to Instance Data supported
4.8.1 getInstanceDocument() supported
4.8.2 rebuild() supported
4.8.3 recalculate() supported
4.8.4 revalidate() supported
4.8.5 refresh() supported
4.9 Feature string for the hasFeature method call supported

5. Datatypes

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
5.1 XML Schema Built-in Datatypes partial whitespace facet not supported.
5.2.1 Additional XForms Datatypes to Allow Empty Content unsupported
5.2.2 xforms:listItem supported
5.2.3 xforms:listItems supported
5.2.4 xforms:dayTimeDuration supported
5.2.5 xforms:yearMonthDuration supported
5.2.6 xforms:email unsupported
5.2.7 xforms:card-number unsupported

Supported types: string, normalized string, token, language, boolean, gDay, gMonth, gYear, gYearMonth, gMonthDay, date, time, datetime, duration, integer, nonPositiveInteger, negativeInteger, positiveInteger, long, int, short, unsignedLong, unsignedInt, unsignedShort, byte, unsignedByte, float, decimal, anyURI, base64Binary, hexBinary, qname

6. Model Item Properties

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
6.1.1 type partial limited to types mentioned above
6.1.2 readonly supported
6.1.3 required supported
6.1.4 relevant partial relevancy applied via a bind to an element fails to apply to child attributes 342319;
6.1.5 calculate supported
6.1.6 constraint supported
6.1.7 p3ptype unsupported 279049;
6.2.1 Atomic Datatype partial We will support simpleType's using length, minlength, maxlength, pattern, maxinclusive, mininclusive, maxexclusive, minexclusive, totaldigits, and fractiondigits

7. XPath Expressions in XForms

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
7.1 XPath Datatypes supported
7.2 Evaluation Context partial
7.3 References, Dependencies, and Dynamic Dependencies partial we probably already do most of it due to our 1.0 work, but we haven't verified we meet the 1.1 standards, yet
7.4 Expression categories supported
7.4.2 Model Binding Expressions and Computed Expressions supported
7.4.3 Expressions in Actions and Submissions partial
7.4.4 UI Expressions partial Scenarios exist where controls contained inside other controls inside a repeat won't be bound correctly 333638;
7.4.5 UI Binding in other XML vocabularies unsupported not a compliance requirement for an XForms processor
7.4.6 Binding Examples supported
7.5 XForms Core Function Library supported
7.6.1 boolean-from-string() supported
7.6.2 is-card-number() unsupported
7.7.1 avg() supported
7.7.2 min() supported
7.7.3 max() supported
7.7.4 count-non-empty() supported
7.7.5 index() partial binds using index() are not working 292333;
7.7.6 power() unsupported
7.7.7 random() unsupported
7.7.8 compare() unsupported
7.8.1 if() supported
7.8.2 property() partial returns basic for conformance-level, should return full. version will return as "1.0" for now, until more 1.1 work is completed. 334333;
7.8.3 digest() unsupported
7.8.4 hmac() unsupported
7.9.1 local-date() unsupported
7.9.2 local-dateTime() unsupported
7.9.3 now() supported
7.9.4 days-from-date() supported
7.9.5 days-to-date() unsupported
7.9.6 seconds-from-dateTime() supported
7.9.7 seconds-to-dateTime() unsupported
7.9.8 adjust-dateTime-to-timezone() unsupported
7.9.9 seconds() supported
7.9.10 months() supported
7.10.1 instance() supported
7.10.2 current() supported
7.10.3 id() unsupported
7.10.4 context() unsupported
7.11.1 choose() unsupported
7.11.2 event() unsupported
7.12 Extension Functions unsupported not a compliance requirement for an XForms processor

8. Core Form Controls

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
8.1 The XForms Core Form Controls Module supported
8.1.1 Common Requirements n/a
8.1.2 input supported
8.1.3 secret supported
8.1.4 textarea supported
8.1.5 output supported
8.1.6 upload supported
8.1.7 range partial 316355; 343523;
8.1.8 trigger supported
8.1.9 submit supported
8.1.10 select partial @selection does not work, select inside repeat may not work correctly, select that mixes itemsets with items may show them in the wrong order 282840; 371595; 372127;
8.1.11 select1 partial There are some resize issues, select/deselect/valuechange firing in wrong order. Getting a few issues with in/out of range notifications. 282840; 303351; 333464; 333529; 352398;
8.2.1 choices supported
8.2.2 item supported
8.2.3 value supported
8.3.1 filename supported
8.3.2 mediatype supported
8.3.3 label partial Labels for items inside a choices element has bind problems. We'd like to expand how we render labels bound to different, unique types. 297083; 343443;
8.3.4 help supported
8.3.5 hint partial problems with hints in XUL-hosted documents and ephemeral message positioning 349667;
8.3.6 alert supported

9. Container Form Controls

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
9.1.1 group supported
9.2.1 switch partial @selected not working inside repeats 339937;
9.2.2 case partial 302497; 329143;
9.3 Repeat Module partial 264329; 273706;
9.3.1 repeat partial We do not support number attribute 302026;
9.3.2 Nested Repeats supported
9.3.3 Repeat processing partial we currently obey the 1.0 rules for repeat
9.3.4 User Interface Interaction partial we currently obey the 1.0 rules for repeat, no support for @number 302026;
9.3.5 Creating Repeating Structures Via Attributes partial does not work for html:tr, html:td, or xf:group elements 340515; 350617;
9.3.6 itemset supported performance problem with large itemsets 372197;
9.3.7 copy supported

10. XForms Actions

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
10 XForms Action Module n/a
10.1 action supported
10.2 setvalue supported
10.3 insert partial We need to better handle when @at evaluates to NaN, and we do not generate unique values for xsd:ID nodes. 303198; 339217;
10.4 delete partial We need to better handle when @at evaluates to NaN 303198;
10.5 setindex supported
10.6 toggle supported
10.7 setfocus supported
10.8 dispatch supported
10.9 rebuild partial is dispatching events instead of calling directly 332231;
10.10 recalculate partial is dispatching events instead of calling directly. Recalculate won't properly mark nodes as dirty if they were changed using JavaScript interfaces. 332231; 349805;
10.11 revalidate partial is dispatching events instead of calling directly 332231;
10.12 refresh partial is dispatching events instead of calling directly 332231;
10.13 reset supported
10.14 load partial no xforms-link-error generated if @src invalid 333782;
10.15 send supported
10.16 message partial output inside message doesn't work correctly 366886;
10.17 Conditional Execution of XForms Actions supported
10.18 Iteration of XForms Actions supported

11. XForms Submission Model

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
11.1 submission partial From 1.1 we do not yet support @mode, @indent, @replace='text', @separator, @serialize, @target, header or method child elements
11.2 xforms-submit partial We currently limit (for security reasons) submission only back to the server that served the document. But the user can choose to remove this restriction on a site by site basis via a preference. Click for more details. 330557;
11.3 xforms-submit-serialize supported
11.4 xforms-submit-done supported
11.5 xforms-submit-error supported
11.6.1 resource supported
11.7.1 method unsupported
11.8 header unsupported
11.8.1 name unsupported
11.8.2 value unsupported
11.9 Submission Options supported
11.9.1 The get Submission Method supported
11.9.2 The post, multipart-post, form-data-post, and urlencoded-post Submission Methods supported
11.9.3 The put Submission Method supported
11.9.4 The delete Submission Method unsupported
11.9.5 Serialization as application/xml supported
11.9.6 Serialization as multipart/related partial 330557;
11.9.7 Serialization as multipart/form-data supported
11.9.8 Serialization as application/x-www-form-urlencoded supported
11.10 Replacing Data with the Submission Response partial @replace with value of 'text' not supported
11.11 Integration with SOAP supported

G. XForms and Styling

Section Title Status Notes Bugs
G.1 Pseudo-classes partial :read-only and :read-write are suported using :-moz-read-only and :-moz-read-write 313111;
G.2 Pseudo-elements unsupported We support ::value, ::repeat-index, and ::repeat-item through the attributes xf-value, xf-repeat-index, and xf-repeat-item. 271724;

12. Security and Cross Domain Submission

By default, Mozilla's XForms implementation does not allow cross domain transactions. This means that a XForm loaded from one web domain will NOT be allowed, by default, to load data or submit data to a domain different from the domain that served the XForm. This policy also includes port numbers as well as protocols. So a form loaded from may not access,, or

However, Mozilla's XForms implementation does allow the user to override this restriction by using a whitelist.

  1. In Mozilla Firefox, open to the browser's preferences by selecting File->Tools->Options... from the browser menubar
  2. Choose the "Security" section
  3. Check the "Allow XForms to access other domains" checkbox. By selecting this option you are allowing all cross domain transactions made by trusted sites, including submission and external instance loading.
  4. Click on the "Allowed Sites" pushbutton for this item
  5. Enter each domain that you choose to trust to serve XForms which initiate cross domain transactions, and choose whether it can load or send data (or both). For example, if the form needs to to load instance data from, then you need to add Load permission for on the Allowed Sites list.

Note: you'll see a "XForms Error (14): Security check failed!" error in your JavaScript Console if a cross-domain transaction is initiated by a XForm loaded from a domain that is not whitelisted.

Note also, that the cross domain check also includes forms loaded from file://. Forms loaded from that URL should be local files, and thus trusted, but it is not always the case. So there is no automatic "whitelisting" of local files.

13. Styling XForms

Pseudo classes

In the W3C XForms specification, pseudo-classes can be used to select elements based on XForms criteria.  This release of the Mozilla XForms product does support pseudo-classes, with the exception of :read-only and :read-write. Until Mozilla supports these pseudo classes on elements in general, Mozilla XForms authors may use :-moz-read-only and :-moz-read-write.   For example, to give all inputs values a blue background if they are readonly, the following CSS is used:

	@namespace xf url("");
	xf|input:-moz-read-only .xf-value {
	  background-color: blue;

Supported pseudo-classes in this release are :valid, :invalid, :enabled, :disabled, :required, :optional, :-moz-read-write and :-moz-read-only.

Pseudo Elements

There is currently no support for pseudo elements. Instead the author can use the normal classes xf-value, xf-repeat-index and xf-repeat-item.

14. Comments and Filing Bugs


Please see the Mozilla XForms project page for the latest information about forums being used to discuss Mozilla XForms.

Filing Bugs

If problems are found with the Mozilla XForms product, a bug should be opened against the XForms component, using Mozilla's bug-reporting mechanism.

15. Where to Find More Information

Limitations and Custom Extensions

As this is still a preview release, there are still a few bugs and limitations (as can be seen above). This page describes the major limitations and the Mozilla XForms custom extensions to the XForms standard.

Mozilla XForms Project

Information regarding the XForms initiative for Mozilla. It contains the list of contacts for the project, an abstract summary, and a list of features with associated bugs.

W3C XForms

Site detailing the XForms specifications (1.0 and 1.1). Details the history of the specification, working group, and supported applications and browsers. Also contains an XForms 1.0 test suite and a link to an XForms validator.